A blunt line — “everything else is horse s—” — from a studio‑boss critique has gone viral this week, colliding with the Emmy rush and a comedy that just scored a record‑breaking 23 nominations. The remark, published Aug. 28, 2025, has prompted swift online backlash and defensive industry voices, raising stakes for awards voters and PR teams. Expect shifting impressions for nominees, rapid social debate, and possible campaign fallout as studios, talent and voters react ahead of final ballots.
Why a single profane line changed Emmy season headlines this week
- Tom Rothman criticized Apple TV+ comedy on Aug. 28, 2025, sparking industry debate.
- The show holds 23 Emmy nominations, intensifying the quote’s visibility and impact.
- Actors and outlets pushed back, framing the line as satire vs. insult.
- Next steps: Emmy voting and awards campaigning continue through fall 2025.
How the viral quote spread across outlets and social feeds in 24 hours
Pluto TV’s Hidden Movie Section Rivals Premium Services
Korean Netflix Has 200+ Shows US Version Doesn’t Stream
Tom Rothman told an interviewer there’s “a kernel of brilliant truth” in the satire, then added that “everything else is horse s—,” a line that quickly ran through trades and X/Twitter. The profanity‑charged phrasing landed during a high‑visibility week for the show, amplifying reactions among peers and fans. The initial trade report and rapid reposts turned the comment into a headline, forcing studios and PR teams to manage narratives while Emmy ballots circulate.
Sony CEO Tom Rothman slams the Emmy-nominated series "The Studio," calling out its inaccuracies:
“In each one of those episodes, there is a kernel of brilliant, blinding truth, and that’s what makes great satire. The show is wonderfully satiric. Besides that kernel, everything… pic.twitter.com/6tfSWJVtHx
— Variety (@Variety) August 28, 2025
Why some industry insiders defend the remark while others call it damaging in 2025
Netflix reveals economics behind 3-season cancellations as viewership metrics drop
YouTube Premium Originals Nobody Talks About Are Award-Winning
Defenders say the line recognizes satire’s role; critics argue a top exec publicly dismissing a hit series can cost goodwill with talent and voters. The split maps to different incentives: studios protecting reputations vs. talent protecting creative legitimacy. With 10 acting nominations for the show and heavy industry attention, reactions are loud — social media outrage, protective interviews from cast, and trade analyses all feed one another, widening the controversy.
Sony CEO Tom Rothman Says 'The Studio' Is Mostly "Horse****" But It Has "Kernel Of Brilliant, Blinding Truth" https://t.co/kHRXHA1gvK
— Deadline (@DEADLINE) August 29, 2025
The measurable data reshaping this dispute around the show and awards
| KPI | Value + Unit | Scope/Date | Change/Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Emmy nominations | 23 nominations | U.S., 2025 | Record for a debut comedy season |
| Acting nominations from the series | 10 nominations | U.S., 2025 | Large acting presence shifts voter focus |
| Article publication | Aug 28, 2025 | Variety interview | Sparked same‑week social amplification |
| Major trade reposts on X/Twitter | 2 confirmed posts | Aug 28–30, 2025 | Accelerated viral spread across feeds |
Summary: High nomination counts + fast trade reposting magnified a single remark into campaign risk.
Who made the remark and what it could mean for nominees and campaigns
Tom Rothman, CEO of Sony Pictures Motion Picture Group, made the comment in a trade interview while discussing Seth Rogen’s Emmy‑nominated satire. Because the show is both a critical darling and a campaign juggernaut, a senior‑executive dismissal in a public forum risks shifting perceptions among voters and industry peers. Expect PR teams to emphasize context, talent to foreground creative intent, and awards strategists to monitor whether the controversy affects late‑stage campaigning or voter sentiment.
Sources
- https://variety.com/2025/tv/news/sony-ceo-the-studio-seth-rogen-1236501283/
- https://deadline.com/2025/08/seth-rogen-the-studio-cast-uncensored-interview-1236490749/
- https://emmys.com/awards/nominees-winners
Jessica Morrison is a seasoned entertainment writer with over a decade of experience covering television, film, and pop culture. After earning a degree in journalism from New York University, she worked as a freelance writer for various entertainment magazines before joining red94.net. Her expertise lies in analyzing television series, from groundbreaking dramas to light-hearted comedies, and she often provides in-depth reviews and industry insights. Outside of writing, Jessica is an avid film buff and enjoys discovering new indie movies at local festivals.