Blake Lively just made a bombshell accusation against Justin Baldoni. Her legal team claims he destroyed critical evidence. Court filings from October 22, 2025 reveal the stunning allegation. The It Ends with Us stars remain locked in an explosive legal battle.
🔥 Quick Facts:
- Blake Lively alleges Justin Baldoni used auto-deleting app Signal
- Legal team claims evidence was intentionally destroyed by October 22, 2025
- $400 million lawsuit between the two movie co-stars ongoing
- Auto-deleted voice memos allegedly used to hide smear campaign messages
- On-set sexual harassment allegations sparked the December 2024 lawsuit
What Happened in New Legal Filings?
Blake Lively’s lawyers filed explosive documents accusing Baldoni of destroying evidence. According to court filings released October 22, 2025, Lively’s team claims the defendants deliberately concealed critical data. The accusation centers on using an app specifically designed to erase communications automatically.
Baldoni’s team allegedly used the Signal application to delete crucial conversations. Voice memos with auto-delete features also allegedly disappeared. Lively’s legal representatives claim this was done intentionally to hide a coordinated smear campaign. The allegations suggest a calculated effort to destroy incriminating evidence.
“They destroyed and/or failed to preserve important data using auto-deleted voice memos and Signal messages.”
The couple worked together on the Colleen Hoover adaptation released in August 2024. Behind-the-scenes tension allegedly erupted during filming. Baldoni both directed and starred in the romantic drama alongside Lively.
Why This Evidence Destruction Matters
This evidence destruction accusation dramatically escalates the legal conflict. Destroyed evidence often signals consciousness of guilt in legal proceedings. Courts take spoliation—intentional destruction of evidence—extremely seriously. It can lead to severe sanctions and damages.
Lively’s sexual harassment allegations from December 2024 form the case foundation. She claims Baldoni created a hostile work environment on set. She further alleges he then orchestrated a smear campaign to damage her reputation. Now her team claims he deleted the digital proof.
The auto-deleting apps allegedly used leave no backup copies. These platforms permanently erase messages after a set period. This makes recovery and investigation nearly impossible for prosecutors. Lively’s lawyers argue this shows deliberate concealment tactics.
The Legal Battle Timeline
The conflict between these two co-stars has evolved over months. Here’s how the major events unfolded:
| Date | Major Development |
|---|---|
| August 2024 | It Ends with Us film released in theaters |
| December 20, 2024 | Blake Lively files sexual harassment complaint |
| January 16, 2025 | Baldoni files $400 million countersuit |
| December 31, 2024 | Baldoni sues The New York Times for libel |
| October 22, 2025 | New evidence destruction allegations filed |
The lawsuit has involved multiple parties and legal maneuvers. Lively’s husband Ryan Reynolds was also named in Baldoni’s $400 million lawsuit. The New York Times was added to the cases later after reporting Lively’s story. Each filing introduces new allegations and counterclaims.
What Happens Next in Court?
Several critical developments could emerge from these evidence destruction claims:
- Judges may demand device records from tech companies to find deleted messages
- Spoliation sanctions could be imposed on Baldoni’s legal team immediately
- Adverse inferences might be drawn against Baldoni in court proceedings
- Federal investigators could become involved given the severity of allegations
- Settlement negotiations may intensify or stall completely depending on evidence
Courts have powerful tools to compel evidence disclosure. Tech companies maintain backup servers. Digital forensics experts can sometimes recover deleted data. Lively’s team may push for aggressive discovery efforts. The judge could force preservation of all remaining communications immediately.
Does This Signal the End for Both Careers?
The mounting legal accusations paint a troubling picture for both parties. Yet celebrity careers have survived worse storms. Public opinion remains sharply divided about who bears responsibility. Baldoni’s theatrical projects have faced boycott calls. Lively’s reputation also took damage during the conflict. Both now face serious legal jeopardy from these new claims. The evidence destruction allegations represent a critical turning point. If courts find the allegations credible, consequences could be severe. You’re watching one of Hollywood’s messiest legal battles unfold in real time. Will justice prevail for either side?
Sources
- Deadline – Reported evidence destruction allegations and Signal app usage claims
- BBC News – Comprehensive timeline of Lively-Baldoni legal dispute details
- Yahoo Entertainment – Coverage of auto-deleted voice memos and destruction tactics
Similar posts:
- Blake Lively accuses Justin Baldoni of destroying evidence using encrypted Signal app
- Justin Baldoni accused of destroying evidence using encrypted app Signal in Blake Lively lawsuit
- Blake Lively’s lawyers allege Justin Baldoni used auto-deleting app Signal for smear campaign
- Justin Baldoni faces evidence destruction allegations as Blake Lively team exposes auto-deleted messages
- Justin Baldoni allegedly used Signal app to delete smear campaign messages vs Blake Lively
Daniel Harris is a specialist journalist focused on the crossroads of breaking news, extraordinary history, and enduring legends. With a background in historical research and storytelling, he blends timely reporting with timeless narratives, making complex events and ancient myths resonate with today’s readers. Daniel’s work often uncovers surprising links between present-day headlines and legendary tales, offering unique perspectives that captivate diverse audiences. Beyond reporting, he is passionate about preserving oral traditions and exploring how extraordinary stories continue to shape culture and identity.