Amy Robach’s friends express hesitation over engagement to T.J. Holmes

After announcing their engagement on October 14, 2025, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes face unexpected hesitation from close friends. The former GMA3 cohosts revealed they’ve been engaged for over a month via their “Amy & T.J.” podcast. Yet insider sources reveal their inner circle remains lukewarm about their upcoming wedding.

What Happened: The Engagement Announcement

The couple shared their big news on their joint podcast, surprising fans with the revelation. Robach said she felt incredibly happy about the engagement. She revealed her parents noticed most was her visible joy, not the ring itself.

Holmes explained they wanted to control the narrative. He said they’ve learned from past scandals to speak first. The pair discussed how they’ve worn the ring publicly for weeks now. Robach attended three massive football games wearing the ring proudly. She expected someone to notice and mention it. Surprisingly, nobody commented on it.

“I think a lot of people who are close to us understand what we’ve been through, so they don’t want to pry.”

Holmes noted only approximately 10 people know the proposal details. He urged followers not to believe internet rumors about how he proposed.

Why This Matters: Friends’ Concerns Surrounding the Couple

Page Six reported that Robach’s closest friends remain skeptical about the engagement. One source stated conversations behind closed doors “aren’t of excitement” at all. Friends expressed uncertainty about whether this marriage will actually last.

The hesitation stems from the couple’s controversial origin story. Both were married to different people when they met at ABC News. Their affair scandal in 2022 resulted in their termination from the network. Both subsequently divorced their spouses before going public together.

This represents a major concern for those who care about Robach. Many friends believe she gave up her lucrative television career for the relationship. Since 2023, insiders worried whether she was truly happy or simply convincing herself. The new engagement announcement hasn’t reassured her circle at all.

The Details: Timeline and Background

Here’s what we know about their relationship journey:

Date	Event
November 2022	Romantic photos surface of couple on vacation
December 2022	T.J. Holmes files for divorce from Marilee Fiebig
January 2023	ABC News terminates both Robach and Holmes
March 2023	Robach divorces Andrew Shue
October 2023	Couple goes public on Instagram at football game
October 14, 2025	Engagement revealed on “Amy & T.J.” podcast

The couple launched their joint podcast after leaving ABC. They’ve used the platform to discuss their relationship openly. This October 2025 engagement marks a major milestone for the controversial pair.

What To Watch For: The Path Forward

Several questions remain about their future plans:

• When will they actually plan a wedding date?
• Will friend concerns impact the ceremony plans?
• How will both sets of children be involved?
• Will the couple maintain their podcast through wedding planning?
• What will critics say about the marriage timeline?

Sources indicate the couple plans intimate celebrations with immediate family members only. Both Robach and Holmes remain committed to moving forward together despite skepticism. They seem determined to prove doubters wrong about their relationship’s sustainability.

Can This Controversial Couple Actually Make It Work?

The real question looms: will Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes successfully navigate marriage after such a scandalous beginning? Their friends’ lukewarm reaction adds pressure to an already complicated situation. Both have been married multiple times before, which raises additional concerns.

Both continue to insist they’re navigating this relationship thoughtfully. Robach emphasized the joy she feels rather than responding to critics. Holmes urged fans to ignore internet speculation about proposal details and relationship drama. They appear committed to proving their love is genuine and lasting. Time will tell whether their friends’ hesitation reflects legitimate relationship concerns or simply unresolved scandal fatigue.

Sources

• Page Six – Exclusive source reporting Robach’s friends’ lukewarm reaction
• USA Today – Official engagement announcement and couple interview
• The List – Analysis of relationship red flags and friend concerns

Similar posts:

• Amy Robach’s pals reportedly uneasy about T.J. Holmes engagement after GMA scandal
• Amy Robach announces engagement to T.J. Holmes 3 years after GMA3 scandal
• Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes announce engagement 3 years after GMA scandal
• Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes Reveal Engagement On Oct 14, 2025, Why It Matters Now
• Keanu Reeves Addresses Alexandra Grant Marriage Rumors Hours Ago – What This Means For You