All I Want for Christmas Is You just delivered Mariah Carey an unexpected holiday gift. A federal judge dismissed a copyright lawsuit and ordered the plaintiffs to pay the Queen of Christmas more than $92,000 in sanctions just days before the holidays arrive.
🔥 Quick Facts
- Andy Stone and Troy Powers sued Mariah Carey in November 2023 claiming copyright infringement
- The plaintiffs demanded at least $20 million in damages for their 1989 song with the same title
- A judge dismissed the case in March 2025 and awarded $92,303.20 in sanctions to Carey
- The 1994 Christmas classic continues earning Carey $2.5 to $3 million annually in royalties
Legal Victory in Latest Copyright Challenge
America’s Next Top Model documentary drops today on Netflix with shocking revelations
Dana Eden dies at 52, Tehran producer found dead in Athens hotel
Mariah Carey may have some extra Christmas cash this year after a stunning legal win. According to court documents obtained by Complex, the judge who dismissed the lawsuit found it lacked merit and determined there was good reason to deter people from filing baseless claims against the superstar.
The December 23 ruling ordered Andy Stone and Troy Powers to pay the singer $92,303.20 in sanctions. Several thousand more were ordered to be paid to other individuals involved in the case, bringing the total tab to nearly $110,000. This marks another victory for Carey, who first defeated a similar lawsuit in March 2025 when the court granted her motion for summary judgment.
The Disputed Song and Plaintiff Claims
Tommy Lee Jones’ daughter was pregnant before her tragic death, court docs reveal
J Cole announces The Fall-Off world tour, first global dates in decades
Stone and Powers claimed that their 1989 song titled “All I Want For Christmas Is You” was copied by Mariah Carey when she released her iconic version in 1994. They alleged their version received extensive airplay during the holiday season of 1993, placing it before Carey’s recording.
The men were going after Mariah for at least $20 million in damages as part of their copyright infringement and unjust enrichment claims. This wasn’t their first attempt either. Stone, known professionally as Vince Vance of the band Vince Vance & The Valiants, had previously filed a similar lawsuit in 2022 that was dropped after five months. The latest action represented his second attempt to challenge Carey’s ownership of the title.
| Legal Timeline | Event |
| November 2023 | Andy Stone and Troy Powers file copyright lawsuit against Carey |
| March 2025 | Federal judge dismisses lawsuit in Carey’s favor |
| December 23, 2025 | Judge orders plaintiffs to pay $92,000+ in sanctions |
| Total Sanctions | Nearly $110,000 including payments to other parties |
The Song That Keeps Giving Year After Year
Mariah Carey’s Christmas anthem continues to dominate the holiday season and the music industry. The 1994 hit recently achieved its 21st week at number one on the Billboard Hot 100, extending a previously set record and solidifying its status as a timeless classic.
The track remains on an incredible run, accumulating 78 weeks on the Hot 100 chart overall. This surpasses Dua Lipa’s “Levitating” as the longest-charted song ever from a female artist. Co-written and produced by Carey with Walter Afanasieff, the song has sold over 20 million copies worldwide and earned an estimated $100 million in total royalties throughout its lifetime.
“Mariah Carey may have some extra Christmas cash this year because the judge who dismissed a lawsuit filed against her over her popular Christmas song just ordered the folks who dragged her to court to pay her more than $92,000 in sanctions.”
— TMZ, Music and Entertainment News
Annual Earnings and Industry Impact
Beyond the legal victory, “All I Want for Christmas Is You” remains Mariah Carey’s most lucrative asset. The Queen of Christmas earns an estimated $2.5 to $3 million annually in royalties from the song alone, according to data from Forbes and The Economist.
When the song first dropped in 1994, Carey made $60 million in initial royalties. However, the track has only appreciated in value over 31 years, adding millions to the singer’s wealth every single year through streams, radio spins, and licensing deals. Industry estimates suggest the song generates approximately $9.1 million in royalties from Spotify alone based on streaming data, making it the highest-earning Christmas song on the platform.
What This Victory Means for the Holiday Icon?
The December ruling serves as vindication for Mariah Carey and her co-writer during one of her most triumphant seasons. The timing is particularly poignant, arriving just as her iconic Christmas track hits peak streaming during the holiday rush.
This legal victory reinforces that “All I Want for Christmas Is You” belongs exclusively to Mariah Carey, putting an end to further copyright challenges. The sanctions imposed are meant to discourage frivolous litigation and protect artists from baseless claims. As the singer continues to dominate holiday charts and earn substantial royalties from her timeless masterpiece, this court decision adds another chapter to one of the most successful Christmas songs in modern music history.
Sources
- TMZ – Breaking entertainment and celebrity news coverage
- Complex – Music industry analysis and entertainment reporting
- Billboard – Chart performance and music streaming data
Jessica Morrison is a seasoned entertainment writer with over a decade of experience covering television, film, and pop culture. After earning a degree in journalism from New York University, she worked as a freelance writer for various entertainment magazines before joining red94.net. Her expertise lies in analyzing television series, from groundbreaking dramas to light-hearted comedies, and she often provides in-depth reviews and industry insights. Outside of writing, Jessica is an avid film buff and enjoys discovering new indie movies at local festivals.