Knicks Show Resilience, Push Pacers to a Thrilling Game 6 Showdown!

Every time Karl-Anthony Towns tested his left knee by bending it, he wished the pain would disappear. A late-game collision with Aaron Nesmith during the Knicks’ Game 4 defeat to the Pacers resulted in a severe bruise for Towns. Just hours before the crucial elimination game on Thursday, Coach Tom Thibodeau announced that Towns’ participation would be a decision made right before the game. Winning against Indiana with Towns was already challenging; without him, it seemed unlikely.

Towns didn’t merely show up for Game 5; he excelled. Scoring 24 points in the Knicks’ 111–94 victory, he also grabbed 13 rebounds and distributed three assists. Powering his way to the hoop, pulling down boards, and sinking close-range shots, he hit 10 field goals, nine of which were inside the paint. Each starting player for New York ended the match with a positive score, with Towns himself boasting a plus-26.

“I’ve found a lot of success in this series by attacking the basket,” Towns remarked. “While I can make threes, tonight my focus was on making a strong early impact by driving to the basket.”

Towns has often been a target for criticism, known more for his friendly nature, similar to Dwight Howard, than a fierce demeanor like Kobe Bryant. He also frequently faces critique for his preference for shooting threes over more traditional post plays. During halftime of Game 3, TNT analyst Shaquille O’Neal criticized Towns’ choice of shots, saying, “We’d be having a serious talk if this was our locker room.” Towns answered back by scoring 20 points in the fourth quarter, contributing to a Knicks victory.

After Game 5, there were no doubts left about Towns’ determination. Despite the persistent pain in his left knee after two days of intensive treatment, his readiness for the game was uncertain until he arrived at Madison Square Garden. When asked what convinced him to play through the pain, Towns simply said, “The stakes of the game. It was Game 5. It was do or die.”

Unlike the initial four games which were closely contested, this game was different. The Knicks maintained their lead throughout, with no dramatic shifts in momentum. Even a third-quarter push by Indiana, with Towns sidelined by foul issues, didn’t close the gap to single digits. The final 17-point margin was one of the largest in this tightly contested series.

Pascal Siakam noted, “They outplayed us.”

The Knicks showed exceptional vigor on Thursday. Jalen Brunson was particularly outstanding, scoring 32 points, 14 of which came in the first quarter, helping New York establish and maintain a commanding lead. Despite Indiana’s efforts to stymie Brunson with multiple defenders, he proved too much to handle in Game 5.

“The first quarter,” Thibodeau stated, “established the game’s rhythm.”

Historically, Thibodeau’s teams have been known for their robust defense, but this season’s Knicks have been average defensively. They ended the regular season mid-table in defensive rankings and have performed similarly in the playoffs. However, with players like Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby, and Mitchell Robinson, they have the potential for defensive excellence.

On Thursday, their defense coalesced effectively. The Pacers shot just 40.5% from the field and 33.3% from beyond the arc. The Knicks forced 20 turnovers, dominated the boards, and limited Indiana to minimal second-chance points. Tyrese Haliburton, who had dominated Game 4, was held to a forgettable stat line of eight points, six assists, and two rebounds in Game 5.

“It was a tough night for me,” Haliburton admitted. “I need to perform better.”

Haliburton has experienced highs and lows this series. After a stellar Game 1, he struggled in the next two games, shooting a combined 12-for-31. While he excelled in Game 4, Game 5 saw him largely ineffective. The Knicks focused more on challenging him defensively on Thursday, applying more intense pressure and varying their defensive strategies, something Haliburton should anticipate continuing as the series returns to Indiana.

“Blame me,” Haliburton declared. “I’ll step up in Game 6.”

Haliburton left the court with a smile after Thursday’s game, stating, “It’s just one game.” Despite the loss, Indiana still leads the series. Historically, only 13 teams have overturned a 3–1 series deficit—a success rate of just 4.4%. While the Knicks have staved off elimination once, replicating this feat will require an even greater effort.

Yet, there is still hope for New York. “Why not us?” Towns posed on TNT when asked about the Knicks’ outlook before the game. With star players like Towns and a defense that proved effective in Game 5, the Knicks have shown they can contend with the Pacers. Thibodeau’s willingness to delve deeper into his bench, bringing in players like Delon Wright and Landry Shamet, has ignited a spark within the team.

“From the first player to the fifteenth, everyone is performing incredibly, with a strong desire to win and support each other,” Towns said. “This team is special.”

The team will have an opportunity to make an impact in Indiana. From Brunson to Towns, Shamet to Wright, it will require a collective effort to extend the series yet again. As the final seconds ticked down on Thursday, chants of Knicks-in-seven echoed through a packed Madison Square Garden, signaling New York’s hope to replicate their performance.

More NBA Coverage on Sports Illustrated