7 September 2025 Streaming Picks That Surprise Fans – Where To Start

Created on:

By: Jessica Morrison

Why These 7 Picks Will Actually Change Your September Watchlist

  • Disney’s “Lilo & Stitch” Streams Sept 3 on Disney+; it grossed $1 billion worldwide.
  • Spike Lee’s “Highest 2 Lowest” Arrives Sept 5 On Apple TV+, Cannes praise included.
  • A24’s “Friendship” Streams Sept 5 On HBO Max; indie hit grossed $16M domestically.
  • Alex Garland’s “Warfare” Drops Sept 12 On HBO Max; real-time combat thriller buzzes festivals.
  • Deadline’s calendar lists dozens of returning TV premieres throughout September 2025.

The Top 7 Picks That Will Redefine Your September Streaming Queue

1 – Lilo & Stitch (Sept 3, Disney+) – Why A $1B Family Hit Still Demands Your Sofa

Disney’s live-action Lilo & Stitch is the month’s seismic event: $1 billion worldwide before streaming. If you loved the original, expect bigger production value and the same heart – and yes, families will swarm Disney+ opening weekend.

2 – Highest 2 Lowest (Sept 5, Apple TV+) – Spike Lee + Denzel: A Cannes-Approved Twist

Spike Lee’s New York take on Kurosawa’s classic stars Denzel Washington and arrives after a strong Cannes run. It’s a moral-thriller that critics flagged as sensational – perfect if you want a tense, awards-season talking point.

3 – Friendship (Sept 5, HBO Max) – A24’s Dark Comedy That Quietly Became A Cult Hit

A24’s Tim Robinson-Paul Rudd black comedy made $16M in limited release and surprised audiences with its weird charm. If dark absurdity is your jam, this one will haunt your group chat.

4 – Warfare (Sept 12, HBO Max) – Alex Garland’s Real-Time Combat Drama You’ll Rewatch For Details

Garland’s ensemble combat thriller trades scale for claustrophobic intensity; critics praised its craft though box office trailed. Watch it if you crave cinematic ideas that stick with you after the credits.

5 – The Wedding Banquet (Sept 8, Paramount+) – A Modern Rom-Com Reboot That Ups The Stakes

Andrew Ahn’s take on Ang Lee’s classic blends queer family drama with sharp cultural comedy. If you like romance with teeth, this one offers both laughs and emotional payoff.

6 – All Of You (Sept 26, Apple TV+) – Brett Goldstein’s Romantic Debut That Could Surprise Fans

Brett Goldstein co-wrote and stars in this adults-only romantic dramedy; expect witty banter and a breezy twist on soulmate matchmaking. If you liked Ted Lasso’s heart, start here.

7 – The Man In My Basement (Sept 26, Hulu) – A Creepy Thriller Premiering After Toronto Buzz

Adapted from Walter Mosley and featuring Willem Dafoe, this eerie prize pick arrived at TIFF and promises slow-burn dread. If psychological frights are your thing, add this to late-night watching.

The 3 Figures That Show September’s Streaming Punch

KPI Value + Unit Change/Impact
Featured Titles 24 titles Variety’s curated September list
Lilo & Stitch Box Office $1,000,000,000 Highest 2025 theatrical grosser
Friendship Domestic Gross $16,000,000 Strong indie performance pre-stream

Streaming’s September slate mixes a $1B blockbuster with indie A24 strength.

Which September Stream Will Take Over Your Social Feed – Which Will You Start Tonight?

Between a family behemoth, Cannes buzz, and A24’s cult bite, September’s releases split audiences fast. Pick the blockbuster if you want the watercooler moment, or the A24/indie titles if you want to be the friend who recommends something unexpected. Ready to pick one and start a reaction thread – which will it be tonight?

Sources

  • https://variety.com/lists/best-movies-streaming-september-2025/
  • https://deadline.com/2025/09/2025-tv-premiere-dates-1235811038/

Similar posts:

Leave a Comment