Three Wisest Men: Tyler Hynes, Paul Campbell return for third Hallmark movie

Created on:

By: Daniel Harris

Tyler Hynes, Paul Campbell, and Andrew Walker bring the beloved Brenner brothers back for one final holiday romp. Hallmark’s “Three Wisest Men” premiered on Saturday, November 15, 2025. The third and final film in the fan-favorite trilogy follows the siblings navigating major life changes. This closing chapter wraps up the saga that started in 2022.

🔥 Quick Facts:

  • Release Date: November 15, 2025 on Hallmark Channel at 8 p.m. ET/PT
  • Third Film: Concludes the trilogy that began with 2022’s “Three Wise Men and a Baby”
  • Extended Cut: Premieres on Hallmark+ on Sunday, November 16 with alternate ending
  • Plot: The Brenner brothers unite to host the ultimate Christmas after family separates
  • Cast: Features Margaret Colin and beloved returning Hallmark favorites

What Happened: The Brenner Brothers Return

Hallmark Channel delivered the news fans waited for: the trilogy continues. Tyler Hynes plays Taylor Brenner, who’s deeply in love this time around. Paul Campbell reprises Stephan, while Andrew Walker returns as solid Luke. The trio never expected to make a third film.

Life pushes the brothers in different directions before the holidays arrive. Their mother wants to sell the family home. That devastating decision forces the siblings to reunite for one last Christmas. They decide to put on “the Best Christmas Ever,” hoping to bring everyone back together.

“It feels good. I think the audience has become very familiar with the family and characters. It’s a big challenge for the team to do something new and fresh while capturing what people show up for.”

Tyler Hynes, Actor

Taylor has matured significantly since the last film. Hynes described the character shift: “Taylor’s in a different place now.” He’s no longer acting reckless or immature. The actor confirmed: “Taylor’s just a big softie in this movie.”

Why This Matters: A Final Farewell to the Beloved Trilogy

This isn’t just another holiday movie for casual viewers. The “Three Wise Men” franchise has developed passionate fans. The first film premiered in 2022, followed by the sequel in 2024. Viewers have watched these characters grow and evolve.

The stakes feel higher because this wraps everything up. The family home’s potential sale creates real tension. It gives the story something deeper than typical holiday fare. Fans have invested years in the Brenner brothers’ journeys.

Andrew Walker recently hinted the cast is moving forward with new projects. He suggested no more Brenner stories would follow. This version truly feels like the final chapter. Hallmark producers pulled out the stops for this conclusion.

The film also marks Margaret Colin’s return as the brothers’ mother Barbara. Her character’s decision to sell drives the entire plot. That emotional weight grounds everything in family matters, not just romance.

The Details: Cast, Air Times, and Streaming Options

Here’s everything needed to watch the finale:

Details Information
Title Three Wisest Men
Release Date Saturday, November 15, 2025 at 8 p.m. ET/7 p.m. CT
Network Hallmark Channel
Main Cast Tyler Hynes, Paul Campbell, Andrew Walker, Margaret Colin
Streaming (Day After) Hallmark+ has extended cut with different ending
Director Terry Ingram
Trilogy Status Third and final installment

Hallmark+ subscribers get an exclusive extended cut. This version drops on Sunday, November 16 and features a slightly different ending. That means fans invested in the story get two versions to compare.

The regular broadcast airs multiple times throughout the season. Hallmark Channel typically reruns premieres the following day and weeks after. Check your local guides for encore presentations during Countdown to Christmas programming.

What To Watch For: The Holiday Movie Season Heats Up

Hallmark’s “Countdown to Christmas” event continues through December. Multiple new films premiere each weekend. Here’s what’s coming next:

  • November 16: “Tidings for the Season” debuts on Hallmark Channel
  • “Finding Mr. Christmas” features search-for-love storylines fans adore
  • 24 new original films air throughout the full season
  • Extended versions available exclusively on Hallmark+ subscription service
  • Hallmark Mystery also launches concurrent Christmas programming

The network has dominated holiday television for years. 2025 promises the biggest season yet with expanded content.

Will This Really Be the Last Brenner Brothers Movie?

Tyler Hynes seemed grateful for one final chapter together. He shared his thoughts on filming this trilogy. “It feels good,” he said in interviews.

The actor opened up about the most meaningful gift he’s received. During a Facebook Live chat hosted by PEOPLE, he didn’t mention movie awards or accolades. Instead, he spoke about sharing Hallmark Christmas Cruises with his mother Betty Hynes. She celebrated her birthday right before Christmas.

“To be in this circumstance with my mom in an activity she loves more than anything, with these movies she’s come to love, with all these people she’s gotten to know—that is, by a mile, the greatest gift I’ve ever had.”

Tyler Hynes, Hallmark Star

Co-star Andrew Walker hinted recently that the cast is working on new adventures. However, he emphasized no more Brenner family films were in development. That strongly suggests this really is goodbye to the trilogy.

Hallmark fans should cherish this final installment. The network has built an empire on character relationships and emotional storytelling. These three brothers have become household names through repeated Christmas-season appearances.

Will the Brenner Brothers Return After This Finale?

Nothing lasts forever in entertainment, but the signs point toward closure. Paul Campbell and co-writer Kimberley Sustad crafted this script to feel definitive. The family home situation provides natural ending-point material.

Hallmark has proven it excels at extended franchises. Viewers watching since 2022 have grown attached. But the network also knows when to bow out gracefully. Three films feels like the right number for this particular story.

Still, if viewership remains massive, don’t be shocked by holiday specials or reunion movies down the road. Hallmark rarely passes up opportunities. What do you think—should the Brenner brothers retire or keep coming back?

Sources

  • People.com – Exclusive interviews with cast ahead of premiere
  • Hallmark Channel – Official movie details and scheduling information
  • TV Guide – Complete “Countdown to Christmas” 2025 schedule

Leave a Comment