Chess Broadway revival opens with Lea Michele, Aaron Tveit, gets mixed reviews

Created on:

By: Daniel Harris

Chess opened on Broadway on Nov. 16, 2025, and critics delivered mixed reviews. The ABBA musical revival stars Lea Michele, Aaron Tveit, and Nicholas Christopher. The production combines Cold War tension with romantic conflict in a 2 hour, 45 minute spectacle.

🔥 Quick Facts:

  • Chess returned to Broadway after 37 years at the Imperial Theatre.
  • Music by ABBA legends Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus with lyrics by Tim Rice.
  • Lea Michele earns widespread praise for her powerhouse vocal and acting performance.
  • Director Michael Mayer added new book by screenwriter Danny Strong to the 1980s musical.
  • Running through May 3, 2026 at the Imperial Theatre on Broadway.

What Happened at the Broadway Opening

Chess officially opened on November 16, 2025, after previews began on October 15. The Cold War musical tells the story of two chess champions from rival nations. Aaron Tveit plays Freddie Trumper, the American grandmaster. Nicholas Christopher portrays Anatoly Sergievsky, the Soviet prodigy.

Lea Michele stars as Florence Vassy, the woman caught between both players. The Imperial Theatre production runs 2 hours and 45 minutes and uses revamped staging and themes. According to Variety, Michele’s performance shines brightest in the ensemble.

“Michele is an undeniable grandmaster, with the rare combination of perfect technique, clarion tone, vocal power, and exemplary emoting skills.”

Christian Lewis, Variety

The Critical Reception: Mixed Reviews Emerge

The Broadway revival received divided opinions from major critics. Variety called it “uneven” but praised Michele and Christopher heavily. The Hollywood Reporter noted the production feels at war with itself emotionally.

Critics highlighted strengths in the powerhouse cast and iconic ABBA music. Songs like “Nobody’s Side”, “Anthem”, and “I Know Him So Well” received universal acclaim. However, the plot itself remained problematic, with many reviewers noting the confusing storyline.

The New York Times stated that despite its flaws, the musical revival offered “thrilling gameplay” through the lead performances. Lea Michele proved why she deserves a Broadway comeback after her successful run in Funny Girl.

Production Details and Talent Behind Chess

The Broadway production features Michael Mayer as director and Danny Strong providing an entirely new book. This marks Mayer’s third attempt at reviving Chess following 2018 and 2022 efforts. The Imperial Theatre houses 1457 seats with a $229 top ticket price.

Production Element Details
Composer/Lyricist Benny Andersson, Björn Ulvaeus (ABBA), Tim Rice
Director Michael Mayer
Opening Date November 16, 2025
Runtime 2 hours 45 minutes (no intermission noted)
Location Imperial Theatre, New York
Cast Leader Lea Michele, Aaron Tveit, Nicholas Christopher

The production design by David Rockwell features minimal sets focusing on staircase architecture. Kevin Adams created lighting that emphasizes Cold War aesthetics with red and blue strips. The reimagined staging supports Danny Strong’s new narrative focused on geopolitical tension.

Is This the Chess Revival Worth Seeing Now?

Lea Michele’s return to Broadway makes Chess compelling viewing. Her vocal prowess and emotional range justify the $229 ticket price alone. Aaron Tveit and Nicholas Christopher deliver solid performances, though less consistently praised.

  • Go for Lea Michele’s standout Broadway performance of the season.
  • Expect ABBA’s iconic songwriting to shine musically.
  • Prepare for mixed plot execution despite creative direction choices.
  • Book tickets early; Nov-Dec 2025 shows sell quickly.
  • Check chessbroadway.com for preview performances and matinees.

The 2025 Broadway revival of Chess succeeds on star power and musical excellence. Critics acknowledge flaws in storytelling, yet the Imperial Theatre production remains must-see theater for ABBA fans and Lea Michele admirers.

Will the Chess Revival Last Through 2026?

Broadway’s Chess has extended its run through May 3, 2026. The Imperial Theatre production shows strong ticket sales despite mixed reviews. Lea Michele fans have supported the show remarkably well.

The 1980s musical faces ongoing challenges from its complicated book. Yet the powerhouse cast and legendary ABBA score drive audiences nightly. Industry insiders expect the run to stabilize financially through spring.

For Broadway theater-goers, Chess offers stunning vocal performances and Cold War intrigue. Whether the show reaches cult status or evolves further remains to be seen.

Sources

  • Variety – Broadway revival review by Christian Lewis
  • The Hollywood Reporter – Theater review by Richard Lawson
  • Chess Broadway Official Site – Production details and ticketing information

Leave a Comment