Amy Bradley disappeared 27 years ago during a Caribbean cruise. The 23-year-old vanished from the Rhapsody of the Seas on March 24, 1998. A private investigator now claims bombshell evidence proves she’s still alive.
Kara Brown loses Jeopardy thriller, stumped by Harper Lee clue in dramatic final
Kara Brown loses Jeopardy thriller to Harrison Whitaker, all three contestants stumped by Final question
🔥 Quick Facts:
- 27 years have passed since Amy disappeared from cruise ship
- PI Jim Carey claims ex-police clerk said Amy is alive in 2024
- Evidence suggests human trafficking network involvement
- Netflix documentary revealed new leads but hindered investigation
- Family offering $25,000 reward for information on location
The Case Resurfaces with Stunning New Evidence
Private investigator Jim Carey spent four years investigating Amy’s disappearance. He recently revealed crucial details never shown. Carey claims the Netflix documentary omitted game-changing evidence. Most importantly, he insists Amy was not depressed or suicidal. She was happy and celebrating her degree.
Jasleen Singh fires back at podcast critics, calls out ‘cockroaches’ in viral controversy
Aakash Singh’s wife Jasleen fires back at online drama, defends podcast past
On that fateful morning, Amy was last seen smoking on the cabin balcony. Her shoes remained on the balcony. Her father saw her sleeping at 5:30 AM. When he checked again 30 minutes later, she had vanished. No search ever found her body.
“I’m 100 per cent certain she was taken. She was taken – watched, selected, delivered and sold.”
Bombshell: A Police Clerk Claims She’s Alive
The smoking gun evidence involves Herman Goilo, a clerk at the police station in Curacao. Goilo first contacted the family in 1999. He claimed to have seen Amy multiple times. He said she looked “fine” but different. He noticed her signature tattoo—a Tasmanian Devil spinning a basketball.
In October 2024, Carey and his team confronted Goilo directly. When asked if Amy was alive, Goilo answered clearly: “Yes she is, but a very different woman. They got her hooked on drugs.” He said the last time he saw her was in 2016. He claimed she was with “a very dangerous man, a drug dealer.”
Evidence Details and Timeline Investigation
Carey identified the band member in charge as Alistair Douglas, nicknamed “Yellow.” Douglas allegedly danced with Amy that night. A passenger reported seeing him bring her a dark drink near 6 AM. Security logs show Douglas returned to his cabin twice—at 1 AM and again at 3:30 AM. These records support a coordination scenario.
Carey believes Amy was drugged and placed in a cargo container. Douglas allegedly acted as the handler. The container was lowered over the ship’s side near port. A receiver waited below with transportation ready. This human trafficking theory explains her vanishing without a trace.
| Key Evidence Element | Details |
| Timeline Window | 5:30 AM – 6:15 AM on March 24, 1998 |
| Suspect Identity | Alistair Douglas, band member called “Yellow” |
| Police Contact | Herman Goilo, police station clerk in Curacao |
| Last Known Location | Curacao island, possibly moved to other Caribbean islands |
| Recent Statement | Goilo confirmed alive in 2024, last seen in 2016 |
Netflix Documentary Reveals Critical Flaws
The three-part Netflix series released in July 2025 reignited interest in the case. However, Carey criticizes major oversights. Netflix featured suspicious escort website photos. The images allegedly showed Amy in 2005. A forensic analyst concluded they could depict her.
But Carey’s biggest complaint involves Netflix’s implications about Amy’s mental state. The documentary suggested she was troubled about her sexuality. Carey vehemently disputes this narrative. Amy came out to her close family. They accepted her completely. The Netflix angle was “intrusive and misplaced,” he argues.
Most damaging: Netflix revealed a mystery website visitor from Barbados. Someone logged onto Amy’s campaign website yearly at Christmas and Thanksgiving. Barbados is where someone whispered “I’m Amy from Virginia” to a tourist in 2005. Now that pattern is public knowledge. “They gave up our technique,” Carey says.
What Happens Next in This Chilling Case?
Carey continues his unpaid investigation with his son Brodie, who speaks the local Papiamento dialect. They work alongside a former Virginia state attorney. A GoFundMe covers limited expenses. The FBI still lists Amy as a missing person. Her case remains officially open.
The main obstacle: many island police are either compromised or frightened. Human trafficking networks have deep roots. Goilo refuses further cooperation despite multiple opportunities. He insisted Amy is alive but won’t provide her location. The investigation needs official support and resources to move forward. Will authorities finally take action before more time passes?
Daniel Harris is a specialist journalist focused on the crossroads of breaking news, extraordinary history, and enduring legends. With a background in historical research and storytelling, he blends timely reporting with timeless narratives, making complex events and ancient myths resonate with today’s readers. Daniel’s work often uncovers surprising links between present-day headlines and legendary tales, offering unique perspectives that captivate diverse audiences. Beyond reporting, he is passionate about preserving oral traditions and exploring how extraordinary stories continue to shape culture and identity.