As Houston Rocket fans, we are all too familiar with the fickle nature of the human body and the fortunes lost and gained on the resilience, or frailty, each one possesses. Ralph Sampson, Tracy McGrady, Yao Ming, and Steve Francis are just some of the big names associated with this franchise that were unable to fulfill their potential due to unforeseen bodily breakdown. Hakeem's knees ultimately betrayed him, but not before he reached the pinnacle of the NBA and enjoyed a lengthy career--many stars are robbed of this opportunity by fate. Whether it is the misfortune of having a body that simply could not bear the demands of the NBA or that one fatal misstep that mangles a joint beyond repair--this is the reality each player faces every time they walk on the court.
I bring this up in light of our myriad debates over Houston's future--a future most of us would like to see highlighted with the addition of another star to play next to James Harden and lead us to Finals glory. Most any fan would agree this is the Tao of the NBA--The Way. The evidence supports that this is true nearly all of the time, but is it so easy?
Avoiding the subject of circumstance, i.e. playing in Jordan's era, or something akin to that--I would point to injuries as the biggest obstacle any team must avoid in its' quest for success. Further, as a GM of an NBA team one must balance the risk and reward of relying on one to three players to achieve success...more on this later.
I found the idea of tracing the history of injuries derailing potential champions to be a bit daunting. Instead, I will rely on my memory and a brief list of this year's major injuries to make a point. (I am also hoping that collectively, you guys can fill in some obvious teams/players I overlooked). I am focusing on season-ending and lengthy injuries only.
2013 Major Injuries By Team
Boston - Rondo, Sullinger
Hawks - Pachulia, Louis Williams
Bobcats - Brendan Haywood, Diop
Bulls - Rose*, R. Hamilton
Cavs - Varejao
Pistons - Maggette, Drummond
Warriors - Brandon Rush
Pacers - Granger, West (6 games so far)
Lakers - Jordan Hill, Howard**
Grizzlies - M. Gasol
Bucks - Mbah a Moute
Wolves - Love*, Roy*, Malcolm Lee
Hornets - Jason Smith, Eric Gordon*, Anthony Davis
Mavs - Nowitzki
Knicks - Stoudemire*
Magic - Afflalo, Glen Davis
Sixers - Bynum*, Jason Richardson
Suns - Gortat, Channing Frye
Blazers - Elliot Williams
Raptors - Bargnani
Wizards - Barbosa, Wall
Teams without significant injuries this year
Thunder (Parker?), Rockets, Heat, Nets (D. Williams ?), Nuggets, Kings, Clippers (Billups?)
Even these teams had injuries to contend with....sprained ankles, nagging injuries that limit the player's effectiveness, etc.
Above, I designated certain players with *. This was to denote a player with a history of injuries beyond this year. These players repeatedly have the hopes of a franchise pinned all, or in part, on them only to find themselves unable to perform. Each situation is unique. Derrick Rose's injury ended a potential championship run last year and has left the team in the middle of the pack with no legitimate shot this year (realistically, that is what...1/7th of his career and he may never be the same?). Dwight Howard makes the list as his all-too-public shoulder injury cannot be ignored despite playing most of the season.
In the playoffs, injuries are even more devastating as there is so little time to recover most any injury becomes season-ending.
The odds of successfully navigating an NBA season without losing key players to injury are not good. By my count, which is subjective, 16 of the above teams suffered an injury to a key player that conceivably ruined their season--whether the goal was to make the playoffs or to make the finals--and we still have about a dozen games left. That is 16 out of 30 teams--53%--so far.
Compounding this with the relatively short window any one player has for winning championships each lost year is a huge portion of opportunity lost. Fate shows no mercy. It is no surprise that the list of previous champions is also a list of players that were able to stay healthy throughout their careers.
The point of all this fear-mongering (which is not my intent) brings us back to the General Manager and risk versus reward. We know that Morey plays the odds. In this scenario there are two sets of odds to look at. The odds of winning a championship without a star or two and the odds of staying healthy long enough to get there.
I contend that the Rockets may be better served by stubbornly refusing to sacrifice depth in pursuit of this other star. Further, any signing we make must afford and allow us to maintain ample depth and re-sign the talent we already have in house. I have already argued that the Rockets current roster has the depth and talent to develop into a title contender. Morey has constructed this roster with the flexibility to be able to shed any players that end up not reaching that potential with relative ease. If Houston adds a player it must be with great prudence for we are one step away from a lost season every single day. By having strong depth at each position this risk is limited to Harden right now--and with the addition of one of the players listed below could be considered almost negligible.
The Rocket's future is bright and I am all for another star. I think the list of players that fit this list over the next two free agency periods is limited to these names (based on ability and there being a realistic chance to sign them):
Dwight Howard
Chris Paul (really small, but I read a post earlier that convinced me it's not so crazy)
Josh Smith (I know it pains many of you, but he has the goods that, combined with everything else we have, will get us there)
I'm sorry, but The Lebrons aren't breaking up and no one else is on that level. If we miss on those three (Howard, Paul, Smith) I believe it will be small moves, if any, until 2015. In my opinion, that free agency class is superior in available talent plus we will have lots of financial options as a lot of money is potentially coming off the books.
Until then, let us all think positive thoughts about the legs, arms, backs, heads, and feet of our guys. It's one thing to fall short because another team bests yours--it's a worse experience to watch time eat away opportunity and potential without ever giving it the chance to succeed--something we all know too well.