Jump to content


Toggle shoutbox Shoutbox Open the Shoutbox in a popup

@  Mario Peña : (10 October 2015 - 01:12 PM) If your part if the Red94 Fantasy Basketball League check the thread to vote for the date and time for the draft event. Thanks y'all!
@  jorgeaam : (07 October 2015 - 08:47 PM) Guys we need 1 more owner for the Red94 fantasy league, if interested please comment on the post in the fantasy basketball thread
@  slick shoes : (07 October 2015 - 06:50 PM) Kobe ranked one spot higher than Ariza? Is this based on legacy or...??
@  slick shoes : (07 October 2015 - 04:13 PM) It was hard to keep up with both the Astros and Rockets at the same time. Should be interesting on Thursday with the Texans and Astros on simultaneously.
@  Mario Peña : (07 October 2015 - 04:09 PM) It was fun to have the Rockets on last night! Right now I'm watching the Celtics versus Milan and Alessandro Gentile is impressive.
@  jorgeaam : (06 October 2015 - 07:47 PM) Well, thinking twice about it, I'd rather have him score less and have the team as a whole do better. Lawson should take a lot of his load off
@  jorgeaam : (06 October 2015 - 07:47 PM) Loving that, hope he hits 30 PPG this year
@  thejohnnygold : (06 October 2015 - 06:15 PM) Someone is feeling confident :) : LINK
@  jorgeaam : (06 October 2015 - 05:54 PM) 10 Teams done, will need 2 more
@  Mario Peña : (06 October 2015 - 02:35 PM) Alright guys, if anyone is interested in joining the Red94 fantasy basketball league we could use one more player to get us to 10 teams (or three to get us to 12 teams). Just check the thread in the Fantasy Basketball forum. Thanks!
@  thejohnnygold : (05 October 2015 - 06:23 PM) I use leaguepass here in Austin with no problems...
@  skip 2 my lou : (05 October 2015 - 03:14 PM) Hey fellas, I'm a rocket fan but I live in the heart of Dallas. Does anybody know if I buy NBA Leaguepass if it's too close to be subject to blackouts?
@  Losthief : (02 October 2015 - 02:24 AM) tks jg
@  thejohnnygold : (29 September 2015 - 05:16 AM) FYI, it was media day today. Interviews are up at NBA.com
@  slick shoes : (23 September 2015 - 06:37 PM) kind of late in the day but NBATV is broadcasting classis Rockets games all day today.
@  SadLakerFan : (16 September 2015 - 04:37 AM) Man, as a Laker fan, I'm learning how little you care about the off season when your team sucks. Anyway, a quick moment to remember Moses. Still remember watching the 81 team as a kid - losing record, NBA Finals. I would have cried w/joy if they could have beaten the Celtics.
@  jorgeaam : (15 September 2015 - 08:30 PM) http://bleacherrepor...ist-after-crash
@  jorgeaam : (15 September 2015 - 08:30 PM) So to celebrate his new contract, Montrezl Harrell saved someone's life on monday
@  thejohnnygold : (14 September 2015 - 04:36 PM) A good article from Blinebury talking about when Hakeem and Moses used to play in the park. LINK
@  rockets best... : (14 September 2015 - 02:29 AM) I agree totally. I got to watch his Rocket days and the man was a hell of a player. BIG MO R.I.P.

Photo

Houston Rockets' summer assignment list: Part 5, Kevin McHale


  • Please log in to reply
41 replies to this topic

#1 Red94

Red94

    Senior Member

  • Administrators
  • 1,415 posts

    Posted 05 September 2014 - 12:52 PM

    New post: Houston Rockets' summer assignment list: Part 5, Kevin McHale
    By: rahat huq

    Management quickly moved to secure head coach Kevin McHale's seat shortly after the team's ouster from the postseason in the first round.  I speculated at the time that the move was more a show of cohesion on the public front (with the team very much in the free agent market) rather than an actual show of confidence in McHale's abilities.  After all, even national observers scratched their heads collectively over some of Houston's strategic miscues.  I noted, at times, the team did not even appear to have a gameplan, appearing lost defensively; and there was, of course, the last play of the season.

    But to delegate the assignment of "learning to use a clipboard" as McHale's summer task would be unfairly reductive and an improper commentary upon the head man's role within the organization.  After all, he's respected, liked by both his star players, and by all accounts, in ownership of full faith in his lockerroom.  And he brought Dwight Howard to Houston.  Those things are of tremendous value.

    I've argued, and others have noted, that in today's NBA, the duty of greatest import for the club's head man is of leadership.  To that end, McHale, having had the ear of his players still several years in, has exceeded expectations.  That is not a common feat.  A coach should be able to lead and inspire and the former Celtic great has done just that, helping the team navigate the tumultuous waters of the Western Conference.

    I've come to disagree with the team's overall on-court philosophy (a gradual process eventually punctuated by this summer's show in the first round), arguing that the team's repudiation of the mid-range game was overall harmful to its intended goals.  I'm more firm than ever in my belief over the necessity of set plays.  But these matters are not at the feet of McHale.  The onus is on Daryl Morey to loosen his influence on non-personnel matters.  Above all, management must hire an experienced assistant head coach.  Not much of this has been made, but I'd argue now in hindsight, having concluded the Ariza-Parsons swap was an ultimate net gain, that the loss of Lionel Hollins from what seemed inevitable hiring was the actual second-biggest forfeiture of the offseason.

    So what should be on Kevin McHale's plate in what's left of these hot months?  Keep doing what you're doing.  Maybe read some self-help books on motivation.  Keep Dwight Howard happy.  Make up some story about how you and Larry Bird didn't actually like each other but found a way to bond on the court and feed it to James Harden.

    McHale should be lauded for his handling of the circumstances surrounding his tenure.  He knew the situation going in, but he's handled the unconventional dynamics with nothing but grace.  It's hard imagining any other legend as decorated as McHale accepting total subordination in his role as he has, and enduring the constant flux of personnel, year to year.  A coach wants to know that the guys he has are the guys he is going to war with - that the chemistry built will be a lasting foundation.  Kevin McHale, day to day, has not known who will be on his roster, with his boss perpetually (and rightfully) holding a glimmering eye towards the next star.

    Much of McHale's value is as a figurehead and recruiter.  I do not think, for instance, Dwight Howard would be in red had the man on the sidelines been 5'9 and spent the 80's coaching high school rather than partnering with Robert Parish in the Boston paint.  But Kevin Love is gone.  There's no one left on the market.  The third star will come by way of trade, if it ever comes at all.  If McHale has been retained for recruitment, that value has diminished.

    With another disappointing loss in the postseason, the Rockets will have decisions.  They might turn to a more conventional hierarchy.  But for now, McHale needs to stay the course and Morey needs to hire an assistant.

     


    • 0

    #2 rockets best fan

    rockets best fan

      glad you're on board, but I been on this boat since it left

    • Members
    • PipPipPipPipPipPip
    • 4,124 posts
    • Locationhouston

    Posted 06 September 2014 - 04:19 AM

    @Rahat

    after I read this article I had to stroll back to the top to make sure McHale's agent didn't write this piece...........c'mon Rahat how much you getting paid :lol: I smell an under the table deal :lol: this McHale you speak of I have not yet seen on the Rockets sideline. couldn't disagree more.


    • 0

    you can only warn a man that the bridge is out.....if he keeps driving he's on his own B)


    #3 Mario Peña

    Mario Peña

      Officer

    • Moderators
    • 2,303 posts
    • LocationHouston, TX

    Posted 06 September 2014 - 04:20 PM

    Good take Rahat, thanks.

    I know there are forum members who zero in on aspects of McHale but the truth is that Morey has the power structure in the Rockets organization set and McHale has succeeded when the big picture is considered.
    • 0
    How sweet it is!

    #4 rockets best fan

    rockets best fan

      glad you're on board, but I been on this boat since it left

    • Members
    • PipPipPipPipPipPip
    • 4,124 posts
    • Locationhouston

    Posted 07 September 2014 - 04:25 PM

    @FSS

    I agree Morey has the power structure, however I disagree McHale has so little influence on the overall picture. I believe Morey has told McHale he wants more 3's and shots at the rim, but he leaves the job to McHale on how to get that done. McHale is not a puppet in that sense. his inability to get the job done is because of his own shortcomings. I disagree he has been successful in the big picture. the rosters he has navigated have had the base talent to exceed their final result. I can only view that as failure. when a coach can not maximize the talent on his roster he has failed in his job to me. plain and simple. the jokes by the national media that we look like we're playing street ball is an insult and point directly at McHale's lack of skills for the coaching profession. if one needs to keep rationalizing why a bad thing isn't bad at some point you have to admit to yourself that it is bad and needs changing. I have reached that point with McHale. even from the most optimistic view the man has underperformed. forget the excuses. bottom line is this is a result business and he's not producing the results. I don't care if he's a nice guy and the players like him. FRIENDLY COACHES = FRIENDLY DEFENSES :lol: a coach has to wear many hats and sometimes that needs to be the role hard-ass. the player don't need to like the coach to be successful.........they need to respect him. I'll stop here because you know I can talk for a month about the shortcomings of our coach. however this final tidbit this man has been a failure everywhere he has been beyond his playing days. he has never done anything that would offer promise that the light bulb is on......in fact I would say nobody's home


    • 0

    you can only warn a man that the bridge is out.....if he keeps driving he's on his own B)


    #5 NorEastern

    NorEastern

      Junior Member

    • Members
    • PipPipPip
    • 373 posts

      Posted 08 September 2014 - 02:14 AM



      McHale was hired to be a "Leader of men", a "person who delegates authority". Isn't that what Morey wanted? Hire the best assistant coaches. Listen to them. McHale is certainly regal enough and respected enough. Contrary to popular and widely held belief, head coaches calling timeouts to set up an offensive play at key moments in the game actually hurt their teams scoring chances. In a statistically significant way. A timeout actually helps defenses much more than NBA offenses.

      Morey, the statistician that he is, is dictating a three and rim heavy offense. I would do the same. The numbers are irrefutable. Motivating Harden on the defensive end is proving to be an insurmountable task. McHale's failure in that endeavor is certainly not his fault. Harden himself has to decide if he wants rings. No one can do it for him.


      • 0

      #6 rockets best fan

      rockets best fan

        glad you're on board, but I been on this boat since it left

      • Members
      • PipPipPipPipPipPip
      • 4,124 posts
      • Locationhouston

      Posted 08 September 2014 - 04:49 AM

      @NorEastern

      LEADER OF MEN? McHale couldn't lead a hungry man to the food bank :lol: his leadership abilities are way way overblown. in what way has McHale shown leadership???????? :huh:


      • 0

      you can only warn a man that the bridge is out.....if he keeps driving he's on his own B)


      #7 datruth

      datruth

        Junior Member

      • Members
      • PipPipPip
      • 162 posts

        Posted 08 September 2014 - 07:10 AM



        what leader, what has mchale done to make us think he is great leader.
        Never won a playoff series
        Horrible in clutch
        Double standard toward players
        What kind of leader is that
        Rockets have talent, but coaching is not one of those talents.


        • 0

        #8 rocketrick

        rocketrick

          Senior Member

        • Members
        • PipPipPipPipPip
        • 1,865 posts

          Posted 08 September 2014 - 12:10 PM

          Ahhhhhh, Yawn. The Texans won yesterday!

          Same ol' BS regarding our Coach McHale.

          The Haters keep insisting "only if" the Rockets fired McHale, things all of a sudden would turn into rings. What else is new?

          How are the Astros doing these days?
          • 0

          #9 thejohnnygold

          thejohnnygold

            Veteran

          • Moderators
          • 4,130 posts
          • LocationAustin, TX

          Posted 08 September 2014 - 02:22 PM

          what leader, what has mchale done to make us think he is great leader.
          Never won a playoff series
          Horrible in clutch
          Double standard toward players
          What kind of leader is that
          Rockets have talent, but coaching is not one of those talents.

           

          I don't mind if anyone doesn't like McHale (see RBF  B) ), but it irks me when people base their decisions so......poorly.

           

          Never won a playoff series?  

           

          That's true.  OKC got us--as they should have since 8 seeds advance once in a Blue Moon.  The Portland series--which everyone loves to hold up as an indictment on McHale--had little to do with him when it was all said and done.  McHale didn't cause that lucky tip in the closing seconds of game 1 which led to the OT loss.  McHale didn't cause Harden to go ice cold from 3.  McHale didn't cause LaMarcus Aldridge to go unconscious from mid-range for 2 straight games (and before people cry adjustments, ask yourself what his options were...seriously....Asik was basically being called for a foul for walking on the court in game 1.  D-Mo?  Sure, we could have put him in....does anyone think he would have done better?  It happens, we were out-classed at PF going into it and it showed)

           

          How about that Lillard shot?  Yup, let's blame McHale for that.  I think it's hilarious that people think that shot going in was such a sure thing, but if we had just got a hand closer to his face he would have missed.  Riiiiiiiiiiiight.........keep telling yourselves that.  Blame McHale.  Channel the hatred.  Gooooood.......goooooood.....let it flow through you.......feel the power..... :rolleyes:

           

          The truth is the Blazers needed a legendary game from Aldridge in game 1 PLUS that last second tip-in to steal the win.  How is that an indictment on McHale?  His star player (Harden) laid an egg and we were still seconds from winning.  Get some perspective, people.  Those two games alone swing the series completely and they were both unlikely outcomes that just didn't go our way.  

           

          Everyone seems to ignore the littany of bizarre fouls called, the no-calls, the number of bail-out shots that the blazers made over, and over, and over....they were way above the averages on those.  It was a perfect storm and if you want to lay that all on McHale's feet then go ahead.  Please, save your cliches for someone who cares.  The great ones find a way!  Excuses blah blah blah!  

           

          No, what's really happening is people using anything they can find to support their desired belief.  It's like walking in the woods, picking up any triangle shaped rock, and saying, "Ooooooh, look!  An arrowhead.  Indians lived here!"  Yeah, ok.  Sure they did.  "Ooooooh, look!  Something bad happened to the Rockets.  Kevin McHale sucks!"

           

          Horrible in Clutch?  Perhaps.  I won't argue that we couldn't be better, but I also would bet there isn't a fan base in the NBA who doesn't feel the same about their own team.  I do know that James Harden was elite in the clutch.  He shared space at the top with some guy named LeBron.

           

          I also know that, despite cries that he never calls a play, or runs pick n rolls with Dwight--that he actually does and we have all seen good ones executed.  It is easier said than done.  As Noreastern pointed out, calling timeouts lets the defense set up too and it's not like they don't know who is going to shoot.  They will develop better chemistry and execution over time.  Believe it or not, San Antonio didn't always run amazing plays in the clutch and from out of bounds--and I personally witnessed them run several end game iso plays that ended in failure and losses just last season....but Popovich is still a genius and McFail is McFail, right?  Ooooooooooh, look....an arrowhead!

           

          Double Standard....wow, this horse is still getting beaten, huh?  OK.  Believe what you want.  I won't waste time on this.

           

          What kind of leader is that?  Well, it seems it is one who has shoulders broad enough to take the weight of the world and keep smiling.  Meanwhile, he has the respect of his peers and former players going back to KG, K-Love, and now our current team including Les Alexander and Daryl Morey (But what do they know, right?).  Use your Google, people.  You can find articles dating back years with players talking about how much they admire, respect, and appreciate the things McHale has taught them.  (please save your, "what do you expect them to say?") remarks.)  If you are going to use hearsay to support your own stances then you have to accept it--especially from an actual interview--when used against you.  That's how it works.

           

          Despite factual evidence to the contrary, Kevin McHale has apparently never succeeded at anything since riding Bird's coattails.  The truth is his successes far outnumber his failures.  The truth is, his failures were destined to fail even if Phil Jackson, Jeff Van Gundy, and Popovich all formed a tribal council and tried to coach those messes.  By the way, if you look closer....he did find success in Minny.  People insist on using his cumulative record there to obscure that fact.  Oooooooh, look.  An arrowhead!

           

          I have grown to dislike this "Leader of Men" tag.  Yet, the results are there.  He leads and the men do seem to respect and follow his leadership.  What other qualification does one need for that title?

           

          Don't take my word for it.  Here is an article that sums it up pretty nicely that followed his dismissal from Minnesota.  LINK


          • 0

          #10 timetodienow1234567

          timetodienow1234567

            Veteran

          • Members
          • PipPipPipPipPipPip
          • 2,596 posts
          • LocationAlabama

          Posted 08 September 2014 - 03:10 PM

          1st tier of coaching = Pop
          2nd tier = Carlisle, Rivers, Thibs
          Nobody else really makes a difference coaching wise apart from setting up a system to fit the players and Morey took over that job. So while I think Mchale is a bottom five coach I don't think we would improve from another coach unless we get one of those top 4 coaches.
          • 0

          Why so Serious? :D


          #11 thejohnnygold

          thejohnnygold

            Veteran

          • Moderators
          • 4,130 posts
          • LocationAustin, TX

          Posted 08 September 2014 - 09:30 PM

          1st tier of coaching = Pop
          2nd tier = Carlisle, Rivers, Thibs
          Nobody else really makes a difference coaching wise apart from setting up a system to fit the players and Morey took over that job. So while I think Mchale is a bottom five coach I don't think we would improve from another coach unless we get one of those top 4 coaches.

           

          Well, here is a list of the current NBA head coaches that I am glad are not here in Houston: (in no particular order)

           

          David Blatt

          Brian Shaw

          Frank Vogel (that's right)

          Byron Scott

          Erik Spoelstra

          Flip Saunders

          Monty Williams

          Derek Fisher

          Scott Brooks

          Brett Brown

          Michael Malone

          Quin Snyder

           

           

          There are a couple of others I am not familiar with to make a decision such as Randy Wittman in Washington, Jacque Vaughn (jury is still out here), Jason Kidd (he knows the game, but perhaps his people skills are lacking?), Steve Kerr (we'll see), Steve Clifford (Charlotte), Joerger (Memphis), Hornacek (Phoenix), and Brad Stevens (Boston).

           

          Guys who I think are solid coaches: Pop, Carlisle, Thibs, Budenholzer, Hollins, Van Gundy, and Rivers.  Perhaps Dwane Casey...this year will tell us a lot.

           

          So, by my count that is 7-8 guys definitely better with 8 more that may be.  We'll call it 16.  Still, there are 12 guys who I am glad aren't coaching our team who currently hold NBA jobs not to mention all the others who have been recently fired.  Anybody want to roll the dice on Mo Cheeks after his year in Detroit?

           

          Does anyone think Karl, Jeff Van Gundy, or Adelman are options?  Heck, we've had two of them already!

           

          Like TTDN said, the number of guys who can truly move the needle from where we are is small.  One thing to consider is this season is the first in many where we, as a team, will be looking to make minor tweaks rather than major overhauls.  That counts for a lot and I think it will become apparent quickly when we watch the games.


          • 0

          #12 bernardo

          bernardo

            Rookie

          • Members
          • PipPip
          • 62 posts

            Posted 09 September 2014 - 10:42 PM

            Brett Brown? I'm not sure why you mentioned his name with the others. With such a crappy roster he couldn't do anything. Also, David Blatt did a great job in Europe, I don't know how that will translate to the NBA but he is certainly a question mark, not a bad coach. With the rest of your list I agree.


            • 0

            #13 rockets best fan

            rockets best fan

              glad you're on board, but I been on this boat since it left

            • Members
            • PipPipPipPipPipPip
            • 4,124 posts
            • Locationhouston

            Posted 11 September 2014 - 01:21 AM

            @JG

            leader of men..........Minny............his time coaching the Rockets. I have examined each just like you, but see something totally different. we could argue the finer points of each case, but I doubt you change my mind or I change yours. we will never agree on this man. I respect your opinion, but those that believe differently from you do have a strong case for their view. I like to think I'm an objective person when I evaluate a situation. I really wanted McHale to succeed, but if you consider what we did in the playoffs should be laid any where else but at McHale's feet I couldn't disagree more. again we saw the same event, but came away with different views. you can have faith in the man, but I have given up hope for him. he can't cut the mustard. change is needed. since the Rockets have chosen to ride with him this year I will be rooting for his success, but unless a talent upgrade is in the works we will be having this same discussion this time next year. you don't have to have an elite coach to win a championship. however to win without one means you have to  have superior talent. we are in that second category. we need superior talent. Charlie Brown proof talent :lol:


            • 0

            you can only warn a man that the bridge is out.....if he keeps driving he's on his own B)


            #14 datruth

            datruth

              Junior Member

            • Members
            • PipPipPip
            • 162 posts

              Posted 11 September 2014 - 06:56 PM

              @ Jg

              again we can agree to disagree

              My question is did Mchale get paid to coach.

              did he get paid for coaching, or was he a fan like us

              the bottom line is that Mchale record in the playoffs with the rockets  is 4 wins and 8 losses. 

              you can spin that how you want to. But you can't change the fact that it is what it is.

              You can make up all types of charts and figures the bottom line is that he has won 4 playoff games and lost 8 games.


              • 0

              #15 SadLakerFan

              SadLakerFan

                Junior Member

              • Members
              • PipPipPip
              • 172 posts

                Posted 11 September 2014 - 07:13 PM

                  By the way, if you look closer....he did find success in Minny.  People insist on using his cumulative record there to obscure that fact.  Oooooooh, look.  An arrowhead!

                 LINK

                 

                Hey guys.  What a rough summer for you (and for us as well)!  Saw the news (if you want to call it that) about Jason Terry.  

                 

                As for his success in Minnesota, he made one great decision, drafting Garnett no. 5 in the 1995 draft.  The team did make it to the playoffs for 8 straight years with KG, exiting in the 1st rough for the first 7 years before making the WC finals.  So, at that rate . . . . .


                • 0

                #16 thejohnnygold

                thejohnnygold

                  Veteran

                • Moderators
                • 4,130 posts
                • LocationAustin, TX

                Posted 11 September 2014 - 10:33 PM

                @ Jg

                again we can agree to disagree

                My question is did Mchale get paid to coach.

                did he get paid for coaching, or was he a fan like us

                the bottom line is that Mchale record in the playoffs with the rockets  is 4 wins and 8 losses. 

                you can spin that how you want to. But you can't change the fact that it is what it is.

                You can make up all types of charts and figures the bottom line is that he has won 4 playoff games and lost 8 games.

                 

                Your question seems rhetorical.  Yes, McHale is 4-8.  If you want to call it "spin" on my part then what, I ask, would you call your use of that statistic?  You took a complex system with a myriad of variables and squeezed it into an over-simplified singularity with which to club one man over the head.  I did not realize things were so simple.

                 

                Thank you for the reminder that I cannot change the fact of our playoff record--not that I ever ventured in that direction.  As for charts and figures--they are but representations of these same facts.  A tree is a tree, but one cannot fully understand it until one understands what makes up a tree--leaves, branches, bark, roots, environment, etc.  It seems you are satisfied with picking up one dead, fallen branch and claiming that makes up the entirety of the "tree".  So be it.  Please consider the rest of this post directed at anyone who would prefer a different perspective on the matter.  I am content that you see how you want to see.

                 

                In case anyone has forgotten--I am not here claiming McHale is a great coach in any way shape or form.  That would be ignorant.  It would be nearly as ignorant to do the opposite in my opinion.  Which leads me to disagree with those who do.

                 

                I love how people use the debacle that was the Minnesota Timberwolves as proof of McHale's complete failure as a human being.  Let's do a short recap.

                 

                1995 - McHale becomes Wolves VP of Operations.  He hires Flip Saunders (still respected as one of the NBA's better coaches)

                1995 - drafts Kevin Garnett (dodging the likes of Bryant Reeves, Damon Stoudemire, Ed O'Bannon, and Cherokee Parks)

                 

                2000 - Minny got the Death Penalty from Sterling.  It is naive to think that they deserved this.  Stern made an example out of them so that ALL teams would cut out the shennanigans (a lot of good that has done, eh?)

                 

                Prior to this Minny was on the up and up having posted seasons of 45-37 and 50-32 (twice) among others.  Yes, they had 7 consecutive first round exits.  What does it matter who they lost to?   :unsure:

                 

                A Rockets team with three future hall of famers, on the road, best of 5....I guess they should have won that.  '96-'97

                 

                A game 5 loss to the Sonics in '97-'98 led by Payton, Baker, Ellis, Hawkins, McMillan, Perkins, and Schrempf.

                 

                A first round exit to the NBA champion Spurs (who no one could beat, apparently) '98-'99

                 

                A Blazers team that ranked 3rd in offense and 5th in defense, on the road, in a best of 5 series? '99-'00

                 

                Another match up with those same Spurs (who made it to the WCF only to lose to the Champion Lakers).  '00-'01

                 

                Swept by the Mavericks (holders of the #1 offense in the NBA) led by Nash, Nowitzki, Finley, and Nick Van Exel on the road again.  '01-'02

                 

                Lost to the Kobe/Shaq Lakers 4-2, on the road....again....'02-'03 (league first moved to best of 7 series in first round this year)

                 

                Lost to the Kobe/Shaq Lakers 4-2 in WCF's.  Cassell and Spreewell were not enough.  Their two weakest positions, SG and C, were LA's strongest.  '03-'04

                 

                After that the wheels fell off.  They had too much crazy (they brought in Eddie Griffin...yes, that Eddie Griffin) and started getting old.  The lack of draft picks, the lack of interest in playing in Minneapolis, the lack of money since Kevin Garnett pulled a Kobe before Kobe and gobbled up all the cap space with his salary and then cried about not having help.  This doesn't even include the Marbury debacle--they couldn't foresee that!

                 

                Remember, all but that last one were teams basically headlined by Kevin Garnett with guys like Wally Szerbiak and Trent Hassell, or Fred Hoiberg.  David Stern killed a team that already struggled to attract talent.  Seriously, out of all of those match-ups which one would any of you pick them to win?  People forget that the West has been a strong conference for a long, long time.  It is not some recent development.

                 

                McHale botched some draft picks--that's for sure.  So do most other GM's (another reason we love Morey).  Remember, McHale had to try and build a team with low second round picks after losing Marbury and Joe Smith with little ability to get free agents.  Hey, it's ALL Kevin's fault though, right?  Sure, because it fits the narrative of McFail.

                 

                By the way, that Garnett trade was pretty solid.  You gotta give him that.

                 

                All 7 of those playoff losses came under Saunders (by the way, McHale went 19-12 to finish the season after taking over for him...not that anyone cares) and I bet you would all take him over McHale ("you all" being the anti-McHale people).  So, that 4-8 playoff record is bad....Flip was 7-25 for Minny.

                 

                I prefer to take a more sophisticated look at these things.  We are evolved creatures and have moved beyond such bluntness as his record speaks for itself.  'Tis a crude, blunt weapon to use.

                 


                • 0

                #17 rockets best fan

                rockets best fan

                  glad you're on board, but I been on this boat since it left

                • Members
                • PipPipPipPipPipPip
                • 4,124 posts
                • Locationhouston

                Posted 12 September 2014 - 02:53 AM

                @JG

                Kevin McHale broke the rules on signing Joe Smith.............it's that simple. giving the man excuses for failure by trying to paint him as the victim in the Joe Smith situation..........c'mon JG. whether Stern was heavy handed or not isn't the point. whether other teams were doing it isn't the point. no use in pointing the finger at anyone else when you get caught with your hand in the cookie jar. McHale knew what he was doing was against the rules or if he didn't know he should have considering his position. sorry he gets NO pity from me. he made his bed of nails and was forced to lay in it. Minny was a FAILURE. outside of drafting the big ticket he was pitiful. the only reason they made the playoffs at all in most of those years was the talent of the big ticket. that's why they were sent packing shortly after arriving in the playoffs. those draft picks you mention......not one can be held up as anything if KG isn't the centerpiece. KG in his youth was a hell of a player........any small amount of success allotted to Minny during that time should be laid at the feet of KG not Charlie Brown


                • 0

                you can only warn a man that the bridge is out.....if he keeps driving he's on his own B)


                #18 Mario Peña

                Mario Peña

                  Officer

                • Moderators
                • 2,303 posts
                • LocationHouston, TX

                Posted 12 September 2014 - 01:52 PM

                I can use blunt simple methods.


                No matter how you spin it Doc Rivers started off 5 and 10 in the post season in his first 5 years in Boston. That's the record, now no matter how you spin guys though I know you all will and trust me I know all the background already so you shouldn't waste your keystrokes.


                McHale is fine in my book but I'm not surprised there are forum members and maybe even Red94 staff that think they know better than Morey.
                • 0
                How sweet it is!

                #19 thejohnnygold

                thejohnnygold

                  Veteran

                • Moderators
                • 4,130 posts
                • LocationAustin, TX

                Posted 12 September 2014 - 03:32 PM

                @JG

                Kevin McHale broke the rules on signing Joe Smith.............it's that simple. giving the man excuses for failure by trying to paint him as the victim in the Joe Smith situation..........c'mon JG. whether Stern was heavy handed or not isn't the point. whether other teams were doing it isn't the point. no use in pointing the finger at anyone else when you get caught with your hand in the cookie jar. McHale knew what he was doing was against the rules or if he didn't know he should have considering his position. sorry he gets NO pity from me. he made his bed of nails and was forced to lay in it. Minny was a FAILURE. outside of drafting the big ticket he was pitiful. the only reason they made the playoffs at all in most of those years was the talent of the big ticket. that's why they were sent packing shortly after arriving in the playoffs. those draft picks you mention......not one can be held up as anything if KG isn't the centerpiece. KG in his youth was a hell of a player........any small amount of success allotted to Minny during that time should be laid at the feet of KG not Charlie Brown

                 

                I know this.  I'm not defending his actions--he got his punishment--fair or not.  However, to ignore the effect it had on his future success is tunnel vision.  I'm not looking for pity from anyone.  Simply a better understanding of a complex situation.

                 

                Those draft picks I mentioned....not sure which draft picks you're referring to....the 2nd rounders he was stuck trying to build his team with post-Joe Smith?

                 

                Are you talking about trading Ray Allen for Stephon Marbury?  Yeah, in hindsight that was a big mistake, but let's not forget that Marbury was killing it for a while until he decided he was too big for Minnesota.

                 

                Wally Szcerbiak over Shawn Marion/Ron Artest?  Sure, hindsight is 20/20.

                 

                He had 2 first rounders over the next 5 years (#26 and #14--not lottery picks) and blew those on Ndubi Ebi and Rashad McCants.

                 

                It was Kahn that traded Brandon Roy for Randy Foye.  (It could be argued that they made the right choice using hindsight)

                 

                I am not even sure why his time as a GM is relevant, but apparently it is.  Strangely, his success as a player does not carry the same weight as his "failure" as a GM.

                 

                I do agree that Minny's success was largely due to KG being great.  The difference is I don't ignore the other factors as if they don't matter or don't exist.

                 

                KG's salary was an anvil and as much as he kept that team afloat it was his contract weighing it down.  

                 

                Salary cap for 2000-2001 season: $35M.  KG's salary for the same season: $19.6M.  That is 56% of the cap (exceptions excluded).

                 

                Salary cap for 2001-2002 season: $42.5M.  KG's salary for the same season: $22.4M.  That is 53% of the cap.....and so it went for years.

                 

                As a GM, there is only one way to get solid free agents to come to Minneapolis: lots of money.  Thanks to KG, the ability to do that was gone.  I don't blame him for not re-negotiating his contract, but he couldn't have his cake and eat it too--not in Minny.

                 

                Honestly, the one that hurts is the Ray Allen/Marbury trade.  That could truly have been the difference for them.  I don't begrudge him the Szcerbiak pick--they needed a forward and he was good for them in a Chandler Parsons kind of way, but he couldn't be Robin to KG's Batman--he was more of a Commissioner Gordon.  :)

                 

                Getting back on topic, if you were referring to the draft picks he got from the KG trade that was a good deal.  Two first rounders in a loaded draft that, unfortunately, David Kahn showed up drunk to (he picked Johnny Flynn and Wayne Ellington with those picks).  He also got Al Jefferson, Gerald Green, Theo Ratliff, Sebastian Telfair, and Ryan Gomes.  That is a solid haul no matter how you slice it.  Once again, it didn't work out, but how often do teams get value when trading stars?

                 

                For the record, it's a bit dismissive to turn context and understanding into "excuses".  What a convenient way to sweep away all those facts and circumstances that are as much a part of the story as the end result.  I never tried to lay any "success" at McHale's feet for Minnesota.  In like manner, I don't hold everything against him either and I am surprised that you are willing to do so given the complexity of the situation.  I'm not asking you to proclaim his greatness, just to see the bigger picture.  I'm not trying to change your opinion--I know that's not happening--but maybe, just maybe, you will leave the discussion with a broader picture in mind.

                 

                Personally, I think he is going to wind up succeeding in his role (as defined by Morey--not the fans) and stick around for a while.  Better get used to seeing him on the sidelines  :)


                • 0

                #20 timetodienow1234567

                timetodienow1234567

                  Veteran

                • Members
                • PipPipPipPipPipPip
                • 2,596 posts
                • LocationAlabama

                Posted 12 September 2014 - 08:02 PM

                I can use blunt simple methods.


                No matter how you spin it Doc Rivers started off 5 and 10 in the post season in his first 5 years in Boston. That's the record, now no matter how you spin guys though I know you all will and trust me I know all the background already so you shouldn't waste your keystrokes.


                McHale is fine in my book but I'm not surprised there are forum members and maybe even Red94 staff that think they know better than Morey.


                Was Doc's team underachieving? Based on talent level, I'd say no. With Mchale, he did underachieve based off talent level.
                • 0

                Why so Serious? :D





                1 user(s) are reading this topic

                0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users